Gil Brewer: Desire with a Fever
Read enough Gil Brewer and you start to feel the thermostat creeping up inside the narrator's skull. The plots are built from the usual junk: money, sex, murder, a betrayal or two. Nothing you haven't seen. What sets Brewer apart is the heat. His men don't just make a bad decision. They work themselves up until they need to make it, and then they mistake how badly they want the thing for proof they're right to take it.
The wanting comes first
Lesser noir hands you a woman, has her smile, and blames her for everything that follows. Brewer's better books point somewhere less comfortable. The man shows up already ready to fall. He's sour, broke, lonely, chewed down to nothing, and all the temptation does is give those feelings a face to stare at.
That's the part that gets me. What desire really promises him isn't the woman or the cash. It's a new self. Take the score and he stops being the nobody with the lousy job and the marriage he can't stand and the town he'd burn down if he had a match. No wonder reason never has a chance. The scheme isn't a way to get something. It's a way to become someone, and you can't talk a man out of that with logic.
Florida without the vacation
Brewer used Florida hard, and never like a postcard. Heat, drifters passing through, land money that may or may not exist, cheap rooms, water everywhere, roads running out to nowhere. It's a place where a man can believe he's about to reinvent himself and that nothing he does will leave a mark. The sunshine doesn't burn the truth into view. It bleaches the whole thing pale until right and wrong smear together. Paradise turns into a sales pitch, and the only people buying are the ones who've got nowhere left to go.
His Florida sits inside the bigger map of American escape, the one that includes California and the Gulf Coast and every highway town with a motel sign. The characters drive toward freedom and figure out somewhere past the county line that they packed the trap and brought it with them.
The prose of compulsion
Brewer's urgency can get ahead of his polish, and I'd be lying if I called that a pure virtue. It's part of the charge and sometimes it's just a mess. The repetition, the cranked-up feeling, the reversals coming one on top of another, all of it pushes the writing right up to the edge of panic. When it works, the shape of the sentences and the state of the man's mind are the same thing. When it doesn't, the fever is just noise on the page.
I bring that up because the gift was real, so the failures are worth being honest about. Few writers ever caught the exact moment appetite starts quietly rewriting what a man sees in front of him.
The woman on the cover
Brewer's books got sold on paintings that told you to look at a woman and see nothing but beautiful trouble, and the stories inside sometimes go along with it. Fair enough. But pinning the whole disaster on some fatal woman is usually the narrator's last and best lie to himself.
The reading I like better asks what she's actually working with. What does she have to perform just to get through the week? Why is the man so eager to cast himself as her victim and her master at the same time? Maybe she really is playing him. His fantasy is what made the whole thing sell.
The price of intensity
Brewer had a rough life, and that's tempted plenty of readers to smash the author and his wrecked narrators into one figure. Careful. His biography can tell you something about the pressure behind the work. It's no substitute for actually watching what he does on the page.
Because the real subject isn't doom, not exactly. It's the belief that feeling something hard enough makes it true. Love, suspicion, resentment, ambition, all of it stops needing any outside permission. The crime comes along behind because the man has already decided the ordinary limits don't apply to someone in the grip of a need this size. The temperature climbs. The exits never moved. He just can't see them anymore.
← Back to The Pulp Desk